Re: Side Bending Practice
Posted: Wed Aug 02, 2023 12:37 pm
This is an interesting subject.
As Mr Feathers indicated, there are many designs out there that use light bulbs, barbecue heaters and propane torches etc. There are others, however, that use off the shelf heating cartridge elements. In the case of the designs with heating cartridge elements, it seems important that there be a method to transfer the heat from the element to the bending pipe itself. It's my guess that light bulbs, barbecue heaters etc are reasonably good at radiating the heat they generate into the air around them. As a result, the heated air effectively heats the pipe. The heating cartridge elements you buy, however, are very poor at transferring the heat they generate into the air around them. As a result, if you stick a heating element inside a pipe without something other than air to transfer the heat to the pipe the pipe won't get that hot and the heating element will get really hot and probably burn out. Since you seem to be using a heating cartridge element, I believe you need aluminum in contact with the element and in contact with the pipe to transfer the heat.
It seems many people use aluminum foil to do this. They pack it tightly in the pipe, drill a hole for the heating element and it seems to work. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mic5PHIzBvM for an example of this. Also, my guess is the aluminum pellets your currently using are not that effective at heat transfer vs packed aluminum foil or a solid block of aluminum. Since some of them are melting ( melting point of aluminum is about 1200 degrees F ) it suggests the heating element is getting very very hot vs the outside temp of your bending iron pipe.
Anyway.. my two cents. Hope it's helpful and good luck.
As Mr Feathers indicated, there are many designs out there that use light bulbs, barbecue heaters and propane torches etc. There are others, however, that use off the shelf heating cartridge elements. In the case of the designs with heating cartridge elements, it seems important that there be a method to transfer the heat from the element to the bending pipe itself. It's my guess that light bulbs, barbecue heaters etc are reasonably good at radiating the heat they generate into the air around them. As a result, the heated air effectively heats the pipe. The heating cartridge elements you buy, however, are very poor at transferring the heat they generate into the air around them. As a result, if you stick a heating element inside a pipe without something other than air to transfer the heat to the pipe the pipe won't get that hot and the heating element will get really hot and probably burn out. Since you seem to be using a heating cartridge element, I believe you need aluminum in contact with the element and in contact with the pipe to transfer the heat.
It seems many people use aluminum foil to do this. They pack it tightly in the pipe, drill a hole for the heating element and it seems to work. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mic5PHIzBvM for an example of this. Also, my guess is the aluminum pellets your currently using are not that effective at heat transfer vs packed aluminum foil or a solid block of aluminum. Since some of them are melting ( melting point of aluminum is about 1200 degrees F ) it suggests the heating element is getting very very hot vs the outside temp of your bending iron pipe.
Anyway.. my two cents. Hope it's helpful and good luck.